DOOH's median ROI hides the spread that matters
Keen Decision Systems and Accretive say OOH's next dollar returns $7.97 at best and DOOH adoption tripled. The figure a small beauty network should read is the gap between DOOH's top and bottom quartiles: $3.37 against under a dollar.
On 15 October 2026 the marketing-mix software company Keen Decision Systems and the OOH data firm Accretive put out the second edition of their joint read on what out-of-home returns inside brands’ mix models. Trade coverage followed on 19 October (Media4Growth) and 22 October (Digital Signage Today). The headline is a big number: OOH’s “optimized marginal profit ROI” is $7.97, up from $7.58 a year ago. The more useful number is lower down. The median DOOH advertiser gets about $1.76 back per dollar, but the top quarter gets $3.37 or more and the bottom quarter gets under a dollar. For a beauty screen network, which side of that gap a buyer lands on matters more than where the middle sits.
A month ago we covered OOH getting a line in the mix model: how outdoor delivery data starts to reach the models that set budgets. This release shows what those models say once outdoor is in them.
Marginal ROI and profit ROI are different questions
The release uses two kinds of return, and the gap between $7.97 and $1.48 is mostly the gap between them.
Profit ROI looks backwards at all the money spent. Keen’s own documentation calls ROI “a retrospective measure” of the return on “all dollars spent”, and its response curves are drawn against contributed net profit, not revenue. So $1.48 reads as: across the OOH budget, each dollar came back as $1.48 of modelled profit contribution. The release itself does not spell out the formula.
Marginal ROI looks forward at one extra dollar. Keen describes it as “how much additional return is generated by investing one more dollar”, read off a response curve that flattens as spend grows. This year’s version is narrower again: the next dollar in the best week for it. That makes $7.97 a ceiling for planning, not a typical result. It is also high partly because OOH is small. At 1.6% of spend, most brands are still on the steep part of the curve, where the next dollar works hardest. It would not stay at $7.97 if budgets moved in at scale. Keen made the same point last year, telling marketers to move money “from saturated channels to high-marginal channels like OOH”.
One more reading aid. In Keen’s documentation, a response curve peaks at the dollar where marginal ROI “hits $1”. That makes a dollar back per dollar spent the break-even line in Keen’s framing. If the percentile figures use the same basis, which the release does not confirm, a DOOH advertiser in the bottom quarter is losing money on the channel.
Why the spread matters more than the median
The DOOH median ($1.76) and the channel median ($1.78) are almost identical, and it is tempting to read that as “DOOH performs like OOH”. The quartiles say something else: the spread is wide. A quarter of DOOH advertisers get $3.37 or more. Another quarter get under $1. The release says 89% of OOH investors are profitable. If “under a dollar” means a loss, at least a quarter of DOOH advertisers are not, which would make DOOH less forgiving than outdoor as a whole. The release does not reconcile those two figures, so treat this as our reading, not its finding.
Benner’s own explanation is execution. The release does not say what separates the top quarter from the bottom one: format, creative, flighting, category, budget or measurement. It also does not say whether any of the DOOH in the dataset was place-based rather than roadside.
What it means for beauty screens
- A small network sells into the spread, not the median. A brand testing salon screens for the first time does not get the median. It gets one result, and with a small first budget that result can sit anywhere in the range. The honest pitch is a plan that pushes a buyer toward the top quarter, plus a way to tell afterwards where they ended up. Our guide to measuring effectiveness sets out which methods work at small scale and which need a pilot.
- Fit decides a lot of the spread. A product sold in or next to the salon has a direct route from screen to sale. A brand with no link to the visit does not. That is the line we draw in endemic vs non-endemic, decided, and it is the first filter before any ROI talk.
- “The most optimal week” is a timing claim. The $7.97 figure assumes the next dollar goes into the best week. For beauty that means the peaks we map in seasonal and event planning, not spend spread evenly over the year.
- Check the deal before the model. For a local or high-ticket advertiser who will never run an MMM, the question is simpler: how many sales does the flight need to pay back? The formula is in break-even math for high-ticket advertisers.
- The adoption gap is the opportunity and the warning. Only 10% of businesses under $50M revenue use OOH at all, and DOOH sits at 3.4% of brands in this dataset. Most of the brands a beauty network can actually sign are first-time buyers. First-time buyers are the ones most likely to land in the bottom quarter and leave. This is the same gap we flagged in July, when a survey found most DOOH operators don’t measure ROI.
The caveat that keeps us honest
This is vendor research. Keen sells mix modelling and Accretive sells OOH data and outcome measurement, and both gain when OOH looks profitable. The release gives no sample size, no time window, no geography and no industry breakdown. Last year’s edition covered January 2024 to March 2025. Trade coverage calls it a US study; both firms are US-based, but the release does not say so. Last year’s headline figure was called “marginal ROI” and this year’s is “optimized marginal profit ROI”, so the rise from $7.58 to $7.97 may not be a like-for-like change, as PPC Land also notes. The adoption figures are shares of brands in Keen’s modelled dataset, not of the US market, and the release does not explain why DOOH (3.4%) is so far below OOH (25.2%). The tag may cover only spend booked as digital. For the US market as a whole, see our United States market brief. Nothing beauty-specific is asserted here beyond what the linked Research supports.
Related: How to measure effectiveness · Endemic vs non-endemic, decided · Seasonal & event planning · Break-even math for high-ticket advertisers · United States market brief · OOH gets a line in the mix model